TOKYO — A day after its latest intercontinental ballistic missile launch, North Korea released photos of what it’s calling the “Hwasong-15.” And the collective response from missile experts was — not to get too technical — whoa.
The missile and its launcher truck do, at first blush, appear to support North Korea’s claim that this missile is much more technologically advanced than previous iterations.
Although there is still much that can’t be gleaned from the photos, and North Korea does have an inglorious record of exaggeration, analysts generally agree that the Hwasong-15 marks a significant leap forward in North Korea’s missile development.
“This is a really big missile, much larger than I expected,” said Scott LaFoy, an imagery analyst for the specialist website NK News. “I believe one of my professors would have referred to it as a big honking missile.”
That is one big, fat missile.... pic.twitter.com/Ah5yplFZAE
— Dr Marco Langbroek (@Marco_Langbroek) November 30, 2017
Several analysts noted that the missile looked like the American Titan II, which was initially an ICBM but was then later used by the U.S. Air Force and NASA as a space launch vehicle.
HS-14 had 4 verniers, 1 main nozzle.
HS-15 looks bigger diameter, no verniers, and, as @wslafoy observes, two nozzles.
Notice that blunt shroud/RV.
HS-15 reminds me of the Titan II. pic.twitter.com/aQxK7PSXMS
— Martin “HEU & Santa” Pfeiffer (@NuclearAnthro) November 29, 2017
They are totally trolling the US. The damn thing looks exactly like a Titan II. And given the total missile mass, you think adding even 1000kg more to the warhead is going to attenuate the range much? Sorry Mar-a-Lago... https://t.co/J0KJmGbYZ5
— Vipin Narang (@NarangVipin) November 30, 2017
So, to break down what the initial pictures show:
The transporter erecter launcher, or TEL, has nine axles, making it one axle longer than the TEL used to launch the previous iteration of the intercontinental ballistic missile. North Korea claims to have made these trucks itself, but analysts believe they are modified versions or based on the Chinese lumber truck, the WS51200.
For some perspective, this is what it looks like next to Kim Jong Un. The tires are nearly as tall as he is.
“We've seen heavy vehicle extensions before, but this would this would be a very large step forward for their heavy vehicles industry,” said LaFoy, estimating that the truck was about twice as long as an American school bus. “We know that this is pretty difficult. It took China a while to figure this out.”
The nose cone
The nose cone of the Hwasong-15 is much blunter than that of the previous iteration, the Hwasong-14. This is likely an effort to slow down the missile slightly as it screams through the atmosphere, which lowers the heat inside the missile and means that the warhead doesn’t have to withstand quite as much variation in temperature during flight.
This might be an effort to overcome issues with the reentry vehicle — the part of the missile that protects the warhead during launch and brings it back into the Earth’s atmosphere. This is one of the parts of the missile that North Korea has not yet proven it has mastered.
Amazingly HUGE Reentry vehicle of the new NK HS-15 ICBM pic.twitter.com/IGGJYW1oT8
— Tal Inbar (@inbarspace) November 29, 2017
The size of the nose cone and reentry vehicle on the Hwasong-15 supports North Korea’s claim that the missile can carry a “super large heavy warhead.” But experts think the missile tested this week was carrying a light, mock warhead.
The Hwasong-14 and 15 missiles are likely to have carried only very small payloads, which exaggerate the range that a North Korean missile can fly, said Michael Elleman, senior fellow for missile defense at the International Institute for Strategic Studies. Basically, the heavier the warhead, the shorter the distance it can travel.
If the Hwasong-15 was fitted with a half-ton payload and flown on a standard trajectory, it could probably fly about 5,300 miles, Elleman wrote for 38 North, a website devoted to North Korea, meaning that a 600 kilogram (1,320 pound) payload “barely reaches Seattle.”
Still, with its publication of photos of this huge reentry vehicle, Kim’s regime is clearly signaling that this is its ultimate goal.
The first stage of the Hwasong-15 — the bottom part that propels it off the launcher, sometimes called the “booster” — has two engines. “We’re trying to figure out what those may be and how powerful they are,” said David Wright of the Union of Concerned Scientists.
Wait! The HS-15 ICBM has TWO (2) engines for it's first stage! pic.twitter.com/Nu1quLo7XE
— Tal Inbar (@inbarspace) November 29, 2017
But the second stage looks like it can carry more than twice as much propellant as the Hwasong-14, since it is longer and has a larger diameter, Wright said. “The combination of those two things means it really is a new, more capable missile.”
The addition of two engines doubled the second stage thrust and allows the missile to reach a higher peak altitude, Elleman said. This missile reached a height of about 2,800 miles — or 10 times as high as the International Space Station.
The Hwasong-14 had only one nozzle, and it used four vernier engines to steer the missile. But the newly unveiled Hwasong-15 has two nozzles and no verniers. That suggests that the missile is steered by gimbaling, a more advanced way to control the missile.
“This is a sort of maneuvering which is pretty fancy. You lose the least thrust that way,” LaFoy said. “We knew they’d get there eventually, but we didn’t think the North Koreans were there yet.”