I recognize that such relentless skepticism is unhealthy, so the occasional chance to speak with high school or college students — who still exhibit hope and optimism about government and politics — is a much-needed elixir. They help recalibrate my attitude, at least briefly.
But then comes a spectacle such as Attorney General William P. Barr’s appearance before the Senate Judiciary Committee last week, where I watched practiced masters ply their well-honed thespian skills, giving credence once again to Shakespeare’s observation about the world and the players on its stage.
Democrats brought varying degrees of commitment to their assigned roles during Barr’s guest-starring turn on Capitol Hill. Sen. Kamala D. Harris of California offered a convincing portrayal of a prosecutor, a part she essayed earlier in her career, complete with knowing nods and dismissive asides. Sen. Mazie Hirono of Hawaii had the juiciest lines, but she was curiously still on book, reading her part with little conviction. Calling a U.S. attorney general a liar should be done with more than the casual air of someone commenting on the weather. Barr’s performance was unsteady as he waited, often in vain, for his cue to emerge, but Judiciary Committee Chairman Lindsey O. Graham (R-S.C.) has his “outraged and offended” routine down pat.
Some newspapers must be tempted to assign their theater critics to cover such farces while saving their news reporters for more serious events. There is irony in the fact that while President Trump was once a TV star, his appeal for many is that he alone seems forever off script. His spontaneity and impulsiveness, reckless as they often are, place others’ rehearsed recitations in even starker relief.
The New York Times recently reported, “As Speaker Nancy Pelosi urges caution on impeachment, rank-and-file House Democrats are agonizing over the prospect of trying to oust President Trump, caught between their sense of historic responsibilities and political considerations in the wake of the special counsel’s damning portrait of abuses.”
I read the story and laughed out loud, falling victim again to my acute pessimism. The notion that anyone in Congress is “agonizing” over “their sense of historic responsibilities” was comical to me. Try as I might, I detect no authentic outrage over the Mueller report by seasoned Democrats such as Pelosi (Calif.), Senate Minority Leader Charles E. Schumer (N.Y.), House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam B. Schiff (Calif.) or House Judiciary Chairman Jerrold Nadler (N.Y.), whose feud with Trump is personal and goes back decades. There is simply applause to be earned from a grateful Democratic base.
When it’s their turn, Republicans will be just as happy to switch roles, as will happen in the coming months when more interesting details arise about the genesis of the Trump-Russia probe. Republicans are no less driven by the temperature of their base. Trump-hating commentators often ask what it will take for Republicans in Congress to abandon the president. The answer is, most will dump him in a heartbeat if his poll numbers among the GOP faithful go south.
But then I stop and chide myself. Maybe I’m wrong. Maybe my cynicism runs too deep. I remind myself that I personally know members of Congress who are sincere and do good things for their constituents. I try to tell myself that maybe the Democrats’ outrage over Trump, Barr and the Mueller report is real. Maybe Pelosi, Schumer, Schiff and Nadler have no motive other than an altruistic, patriotic desire to defend the Constitution from the evil that is President Trump.
Before long, though, my cynicism owns me again. I try to exorcise the demon, but it materializes with every congressional hearing, every Washington news conference, every campaign stump speech. What I see is not good government, just poll-tested show business.
Still, we can’t all be cynics. Politicians need the trusting and the innocent. Perhaps this is why the parties target the youth vote, and some even want to lower the voting age to 16, before pessimism takes root.
Democratic partisans and Never-Trumpers will naturally cheer the coming hearings on obstruction of justice and other Mueller report matters. But I particularly envy the true believers, the non-jaded Americans who will watch the proceedings believing they are witnessing history unfold. In their eyes, Democratic members of Congress will be rising to meet their “historic responsibilities.”
I’ll watch the same hearings and see nothing more than the latest chapters of the “Trump-Russia Collusion and Obstruction Show,” a Partisan Political Production that was almost derailed when the attorney general exercised script approval over last month’s blockbuster finale. No worries. It’s been renewed for additional episodes — with a guarantee through 2020.