Congrats — or something — to Chris Cillizza’s winners and losers of 2012.
Worst year in Washington: The tea party
Bad year: Mitt Romney
Bad year: David Petraeus
Good year: The Clintons
Good year: D.C. sports teams
Best year in Washington: Nate Silver
At the start of the year, retired Gen. David H. Petraeus was flying high. He was the director of the CIA and was often mentioned as a prospective presidential candidate.
He was the most recognized and heralded general of his generation, the subject of many adoring news stories and books. He had been the hero of the Iraq war, turning around an apparent disaster with the troop surge. And in 2010, he was called in to take over the Afghan war after Gen. Stanley McChrystal’s dismissal.
Typical of this digital age, the affair was exposed via e-mail. The FBI began investigating Broadwell after she sent harassing e-mails to a woman in Tampa who knew the general. Agents then discovered that she and Petraeus were leaving draft messages for each other in a Gmail account they shared. (Tricky, tricky . . .)
The Petraeus-Broadwell affair just kept spiraling outward. We met Jill Kelley, the Tampa socialite whose closeness to Petraeus had stoked the ire of Broadwell, who e-mailed Kelley, warning her to stay away from the general. Kelley brought Gen. John R. Allen into the tangled web as it was revealed that they had exchanged 20,000 to 30,000 pages of e-mails. (Details of the e-mails’ content are murky, but the controversy has sidelined Allen’s nomination to lead the U.S. European Command.)
The whole episode exposed a military culture that the average person — or at least the Fix — had been clueless about. Generals such as Petraeus are treated like kings, traveling in motorcades and having their food prepared by gourmet chefs. (Gourmet chefs!)
Despite the armed services’ culture of discipline and great reverence for their leaders, the men at the top are, it seems, mere mortals prone to infidelity. Petraeus became the face of that inevitable-but-still-depressing realization: a man treated like a god (and who maybe thought he was one) who wound up being all too human.