The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

Opinion Changing the state flag is not about forgetting Mississippi’s past. It’s about acknowledging it.

Don Hartness walks around the Capitol in Jackson, Miss., carrying the Mississippi state flag and the U.S. flag on Saturday.
Don Hartness walks around the Capitol in Jackson, Miss., carrying the Mississippi state flag and the U.S. flag on Saturday. (Rogelio V. Solis/AP)

Russell Moore is president of the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention and the author of “The Courage to Stand: Facing Your Fear Without Losing Your Soul,” to be published in October.

Until now, the only flag of my home state that I would display are scraps, barely holding together, lying on the shelf next to me right now. This remnant of the Mississippi flag was a gift from a man who served in the National Guard patrolling my hometown of Biloxi in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in 2005. He found the shredded flag clinging to the ground next to the lighthouse, and gave me what was left of it. In time, it fell apart, and all I kept were the parts that held together — stripes of red, white and blue.

For me, this tattered flag was a reminder of the fragility and resilience of my home state and its people, of the ties that hold it together and the winds that have torn it apart. But I love this particular symbol not just for what’s there — bits of red and blue and white holding together despite it all — but also for what’s missing. The part that fell away was the Confederate emblem: the ugly reminder of our state’s legacy of white supremacy and exclusion.

Filmmaker Ken Burns reflects on James Baldwin's understanding of liberty, and how our most venerated monuments can remind us of where America falls short. (Video: The Washington Post)

In a development that many Mississippians had longed for but never really expected to happen in our lifetimes, the state’s House and Senate on Saturday began the process of changing the flag adopted in 1894 as a backlash against Reconstruction. The way has been cleared for legislation, which Gov. Tate Reeves (R) has said he would sign, to introduce a new state flag that, finally, would represent all Mississippians.

Some would say that this action doesn’t really mean much, especially given the very real problems of racial injustice the nation faces, crystallized by the recent killings of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor and Ahmaud Arbery. Skeptics might suggest that Mississippi’s move is just about a symbol. I understand that sentiment, but would suggest that symbols matter, too — especially when those symbols point not toward heaven but toward hell.

The Confederate emblem on the Mississippi flag was a way of enshrining who belonged, and who counted, as Mississippian — and who did not. To fly that flag required, at best, a willful suspension of thought about what the Confederate battle flag represented: an ideology based on the belief that one group of human beings could purport to kidnap, enslave, persecute and terrorize another group of people made in the image of God. This symbolism was not employed solely during the Civil War, but far outlasted it, serving in the state-sponsored terrorism of Jim Crow, the burning of crosses on the front lawns of gospel preachers, the midnight murders of civil rights activists.

What changes do you hope will come out of protests and debates about police and race? Write to The Post.

No doubt some will charge that changing the Mississippi flag is a “politically correct” act of forgetting history. And yet, the old flag was itself not about remembering history, but about forgetting it. The flag told us to “remember” a retrofitted story about the Mississippi of the Old South, while not mentioning the rape of enslaved women, the beating of enslaved men, or, later, the murder of Medgar Evers and imprisonment of Fannie Lou Hamer during the civil rights era, the killing of Emmett Till, and on and on.

To change the state flag is not about forgetting the past, but about acknowledging it. The song “Dixie” said that “Old times there are not forgotten,” but, in reality, the price of belonging was to do just that, to forget old times or else to sanctify them as what they were not — to, as the Bible forbids, call good evil and evil good.

The symbols matter, especially for a people as rooted as those of us blessed to be born and raised in Mississippi. We know what it is to immediately recognize a line by William Faulkner or Eudora Welty or Natasha Trethewey or Jesmyn Ward and to know, “That’s from one of us.” We know what it is to hear a piece of music from a Robert Johnson or an Elvis Presley or a Tammy Wynette or a B.B. King and know, “This is from one of us.” Being free to embrace all of what Mississippi has to give to the world — while being free to lament all that is awful that has come from our state — is symbolism that points beyond itself, to the possibility of a new day.

Whatever the new Mississippi flag turns out to be, I plan to fly it here at my house, a symbol of a Mississippi that knows how to start over, to try to love again. But I’m going to keep my pieces of the old flag here, too, a symbol of the state I love, weathered but holding together. Those scraps can remind me of the possibility that what we love can still stand, while the hate can be gone with the wind.

Read more:

Eugene Robinson: There is no earthly reason this nation should be defiled by Confederate statues

Ty Seidule: What to rename the Army bases that honor Confederate soldiers

Harry Anderson: My experience at a Confederate-named Army base shows why we need to rename them all — now

Christine Emba: Memorials to white supremacy are falling. What will replace them?

David Von Drehle: Renaming military bases is not erasing history. It’s erasing propaganda.

Robert W. Lee IV: Robert E. Lee is my ancestor. Take down his statue, and let his cause be lost.