Who knew? Why did no one act? Why wasn’t he stopped? The questions that surround Mr. McCarrick’s troubling ascent to the church’s highest ranks are unfortunately not new; they echo those that have dogged the Vatican in its response to the scourge of clerical sexual abuse and misconduct. How Pope Francis — who has been able to claim some progress in confronting the problem of child sexual abuse — deals with this scandal involving the abuse and harassment of young priests will show just how serious the Vatican is in cleaning house.
The New York Times has detailed how Mr. McCarrick was made archbishop of Washington, elevated to cardinal and given prestigious assignments (including devising reforms to deal with the sexual abuse scandal) even though some church officials had known for decades of accusations that he had sexually harassed and inappropriately touched adult seminary students. The first documented complaint, the Times reported, was in 1994, and it was followed by warnings that included one priest directly contacting the papal nuncio in Washington. There were two settlements with alleged victims, in 2005 and 2007. “People were disgusted by it . . . I don’t remember anyone welcoming it and hoping they would be touched,” said one former student, now in his 50s, who received an $80,000 settlement.
Mr. McCarrick is also accused of molesting children: a 16-year-old altar boy in 1971 and the 11-year-old son of a family friend who said the sexual abuse continued for nearly 20 years. It is hard not to conclude that the church enabled these crimes and helped ruin lives by turning a blind eye to the clear warnings of Mr. McCarrick’s misconduct. The advances on priests-in-training may not have been criminal under secular laws, but they violated church precepts; in their alleged use of a senior cleric’s power over subordinates they resemble the sexual offenses brought to light by the #MeToo movement.
Mr. McCarrick, now 88, said last month he had no recollection of the abuse 50 years ago involving the altar boy, and he has declined comment on the new allegations. A former spokeswoman for him said he is committed to following the Vatican process. Let’s hope that includes more than being allowed to retire to private prayer. There should be a complete accounting of what happened, a reckoning for any who were complicit and cooperation with any civilian criminal investigations.