The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

Republicans attack Jewish candidates across the U.S. with an age-old caricature: Fistfuls of cash

A mailer sent out about Kim Schrier, a Jewish candidate for a high-profile congressional seat outside of Seattle, by the Washington State Republican Party. (Kim Shrier for Congress/(Dr. Kim Schrier for Congress))

Scott Kendall, the chief of staff to Alaska Gov. Bill Walker (I), said the week after the Pittsburgh synagogue shooting was not easy for him.

A Jewish Republican, Kendall had just spoken to his 7-year-old son about why it was important to continue to go to synagogue, so the “bad guys” wouldn’t win. Kendall had been to memorials at synagogues in Juneau and Anchorage, where he lives, in a state that is home to a Jewish population numbering in the couple of thousands.

And then he saw the mailer from a local Republican group attacking Jewish state Senate candidate Jesse Kiehl with the image of a man stuffing a fat stack of hundred dollar bills into his suit.

“I was revolted,” Kendall recalled in a phone interview, saying he believed the ad was blatantly anti-Semitic. “Jesse is proudly and prominently a member of Juneau’s Jewish community. . . . It is tough for me to process through that and not see an ill intent.”

The ad was not alone.

In North Carolina, the state Republican Party depicted Sen. Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.) with what appeared to be a stack of bills in his hand.

In a hotly contested race outside Seattle, Republicans illustrated Kim Schrier, a Democratic candidate for Congress who is Jewish, with a wad of $20 bills fanned out in her hands.

In California, a Republican state assembly candidate tinted his Jewish challenger a shade of green in an ad, adding $100 bills into his grip for good measure.

In Pennsylvania, a Republican state representative ran an ad that painted Democratic challenger Sara Johnson Rothman with money in her hands. It also dropped Johnson, her maiden name, from the graphic while leaving the one she took from her Jewish husband, Scott Rothman.

And national outcry ensued last week after a Republican state senate candidate’s ad against his Jewish challenger in Connecticut was digitally altered in a way to play off classic anti-Semitic tropes. Democratic state Rep. Matthew Lesser was depicted holding a wad of cash in front of him, with a crazed look in his eyes.

These ads come amid the tense and bitter run-up to Tuesday’s midterm elections, as national politics increasingly pivots on fundamental issues of race and identity.

A reporter unwittingly left a voice mail for a GOP candidate. She was fired for what she said.

But in the wake of the shooting at the Pittsburgh synagogue, concerns about anti-Semitism and questions about whether it is being fanned by the flames of conspiracy theories and political fearmongering have come to the fore.

“What’s stunning is that these are old images that are very similar to those from other eras and other places,” said Pamela Nadell, a history professor at American University and the director of its Jewish Studies program. “But I will say I have not seen images like this in 21st-century America before.”

Nadell sent The Washington Post an unflattering image from a 13th-century Spanish manuscript that depicted Jewish money lenders handing over bags of coins to unhappy loan seekers.

The sampling of advertisements is not a scientific study.

It is not clear whether other candidates have been attacked this way during this election cycle. But national sensitivity is heightened amid rising reports of anti-Semitism and a turn by some political campaigns toward the type of blatant and overtly racial attacks rarely seen since the 1960s.

“There’s some famous Nazi posters that have exactly the same images but with different people,” Omer Bartov, a professor of European history at Brown University and the author of a book examining Jewish stereotypes, said of the recent crop of ads.

The political advertisements have caused local consternation, as well.

In Juneau, the mailer attacking Kiehl prompted conversations both within and outside the Jewish community, residents like liberal activist Karla Hart said, sparking media coverage and angry letters to the local newspaper.

“Shame on the Republican Women of Juneau for using an anti-Semitic trope in their recent mailer against Jesse Kiehl,” Elizabeth Seliotes Bolling wrote to the Juneau Empire.

Oprah Winfrey on racist ‘magical Negro’ robo-call: ‘Jesus don’t like ugly’

Kendall, the Alaska governor’s chief of staff, said he phoned the group that created the flier, the Republican Women of Juneau, and asked what they were thinking after he was flooded with calls and emails.

“I’d like to believe it wasn’t intentional,” Kendall said he told them. “But whatever you do, you need to put out a statement that you condemn anti-Semitism.”

The group, which did not return messages The Post left for its president and another member, has not put out such a statement, Kendall said.

Seth Klayman, a North Carolina resident who has a doctorate in Jewish studies from Duke, flagged the Schumer ad when it appeared in the middle of a news article he was reading online.

“Immediately I thought they were, at the very least, rooted in anti-Semitic stereotypes and at worst full blown anti-Semitism on the part of the North Carolina Republican Party,” he said. “I found it abhorrent."

Dallas Woodhouse, executive director of the North Carolina Republican Party, dismissed questions about the Schumer ad in an email.

“The question itself, not the mailer, is a racist anti-Semitic smear,” he wrote. “It is just one more final disgusting attempt to Kavanaugh Republican candidates and activities. We don’t track people’s religion here or lack thereof.”

He called questions about the ad “the single dumbest and most outrageous inquiry I’ve ever had from a member of the media” but did not answer questions about whether the state party had ever run ads against any other candidates with money in their hands.

Kyle Fischer, a spokesman for the Washington State Republican Party, which sponsored the Schrier ad, said that the ad was meant to highlight her support for costly government policies.

“To imply that the content of these mail pieces is based on anything other than Schrier’s record of supporting policies that would cost taxpayers billions of dollars is baseless and untrue,” he said in a statement.

Schrier spokeswoman Katie Rodihan said Republican ads for other candidates in Washington did not feature the same imagery. (Fischer did not answer a question about whether the party had run ads that showed any other candidates with cash in their hands.)

“It’s an outrageous characterization of a candidate that draws on centuries old anti-Semitic stereotypes,” she said. “Kim’s whole platform is focused on lowering costs for families. This is a complete mischaracterization.”

The Republican National Committee did not respond to a request for comment. In Connecticut, the ad run by Republican state Senate candidate Ed Charamut has caused some hard feelings within the party.

“As a Jew and as a Republican, I was very dismayed, I was very disturbed by the content of that mailer,” Leora Levy, the Republican National Committeewoman for Connecticut, said in an interview.

She said she would not support Charamut or anyone who sent similar material.

Ted Cruz debates a puppet dog as he fights to save his Senate seat

The ads come as political rhetoric has been examined for what some see as overt signs of classic anti-Semitism, with conspiracy theories about Jewish financier George Soros directing an “invasion” at the southern border becoming a prominent theme in conservative politics in recent weeks.

President Trump told reporters last week that he “wouldn’t be surprised” if the unfounded conspiracy theory were true.

Bartov, the Brown professor, said that these narratives echoed classic Nazi propaganda that tried to paint Jews as both capitalists and revolutionaries seeking to subvert the social order.

“Much of the rhetoric is about how the left is going to destroy everything, destroy the economy, bring this invasion of barbarians — all of this was very much part of fascist and Nazi xenophobia,” he said. “It’s this combination of things: speaking about them undermining order on the one hand, bringing in hordes of invaders, and on the other hand, manipulating the economy.”

Kendall — whose boss, Gov. Walker, is an independent — said that it was tough at times to “keep my party affiliation” but that he did not believe that the Republican Party was inhospitable to Jewish people.

“The anti-Semitic tropes have no place in the discourse. The anti-immigrant tropes have no place in the discourse,” he said. “Perhaps individuals are using the politics of division to get ahead, but it’s not who we are."

Bartov said he didn’t believe that the ads could be blamed on naivete.

“It’s not by chance that they’re showing people showing money. It’s not by chance that these people happen to be Jews, and it’s not by chance that there’s more talk about people’s Jewish identity in politics,” he said. “Some genie is being let out of the bottle.”

Post-Holocaust prejudice against the Jews still remains — and it's just one aspect of religious and racial tensions in modern America. (Video: Allie Caren/The Washington Post)

Read more:

John Oliver wants to know why his employer supported white nationalist sympathizer Steve King

An 82-year-old Texas woman voted for the first time. Then she died.

She was ‘white and hot’ in a racist rant. Now #SouthParkSusan is charged with misusing 911.

The schoolteachers who dressed up as ‘Mexicans’ and a MAGA wall for Halloween have been suspended

Judge rules against Brian Kemp over Georgia voting restrictions days before gubernatorial election

Rep. Steve King erupts as his immigration views are compared to the Pittsburgh shooting suspect’s