It soon became clear that this incident wasn’t like the ones we see in movies. Shortly after Cali’s death, a 24-year-old named Anthony Comello was arrested in connection with the crime. Comello didn’t have the résumé of a Mafia button man. In fact, it was reported that police believe he killed Cali because the crime boss wouldn’t let Comello date his niece.
When Comello appeared in court in New Jersey for an extradition hearing that would send him back to New York, he suddenly displayed a hand covered in scribbled text. “United we stand,” he’d written, along with “MAGA forever” — a reference to President Trump’s campaign slogan, “Make America great again.”
Drawn with thick lines at the center of his hand was a large “Q.”
Last summer, there was a flurry of reporting on “QAnon” when adherents began popping up at Trump rallies. It’s a sweeping, bizarre theory that Trump’s presidency was secretly predicated on uprooting child molestation rings and in which an anonymous figure named Q revealed secret messages from within the White House about Trump’s hidden agenda. A president who had based his election on the idea that he was battling a nefarious establishment cabal had transformed, in the eyes of thousands of supporters, into a president battling an even more dangerous and toxic group, leaking “the truth” out to a select few through this anonymous account.
That Comello was sporting a “Q” on his hand in court, though, wasn’t an ironic statement or a wink at the broader conspiracy theory. In a phone call with The Washington Post on Thursday, his attorney, Robert Gottlieb, argued that the QAnon theory was central to the incident on Staten Island.
“The evidence that I refer to, the QAnon, the other hate words and messages emanating from other extreme right-wing conspiracy websites, as well as statements made by the president, without any question will be critical and central to explaining what happened in this case,” Gottlieb said.
The lawyer didn’t explicitly state that Comello had committed the crime, but he added, “What I can say unequivocally is: Whatever happened here is connected to those hate messages and websites.”
After Comello was arrested, the government seized his computer, and Gottlieb indicated that he hadn’t seen the specific online material Comello had reviewed. But he did indicate that Comello participated in the world of QAnon, either passively or actively, a fact he learned from speaking to Comello’s family and friends. They apparently indicated to Gottlieb that, in recent months, they’d noticed a change in Comello’s behavior that they attributed to his online activity and involvement with the unnamed sites.
Obviously, there’s a potential benefit to Gottlieb’s client in presenting him as having psychiatric problems. Gottlieb didn’t shy away from that suggestion.
“This is a very complicated psychological and psychiatric issue,” he said. “The hate messages, the venom that is spewed on the Internet doesn’t necessarily affect everybody. It certainly has a greater chance of having a devastating impact on someone who may be suffering from psychiatric problems.”
“It has a real impact on the most vulnerable people, who, if touched and affected by the hate, can do things which, if they were not suffering from the mental illness, they would have never done,” Gottlieb added.
This would not be the first time that someone appears to have been inspired by right-wing online conspiracy theories and Trump’s rhetoric to take violent action. One week ago, Cesar Sayoc pleaded guilty to charges that he’d sent explosive devices to newsrooms and Democratic politicians across the country last fall. An armed man who blocked traffic near the Hoover Dam last year cited QAnon slogans in letters he later wrote. After several violent threats in September, Reddit banned some QAnon discussion groups.
Gottlieb was careful in how he described what happened on Staten Island and its relationship to his client. He was much less worried about linking what his client read online to the possibility that it affected how Comello behaved.
“Over the past few years, people have been talking about the danger of this garbage that’s on the Internet,” Gottlieb said. “This could very well be the case that reflects that words really do matter.”