Pandemics can be prevented, Frieden argues, but it’s going to take serious investment. Frieden has called for a health defense fund that would not be subject to budget ceilings (the Bipartisan Policy Center has also called for isolated, guaranteed infectious-disease funding).
Frieden talked about that proposal and more with The Health 202.
[This interview has been lightly edited for clarity and length.]
H202: The coronavirus pandemic seems like a singular, once-in-a-lifetime event, but the world has had near misses before. Tell me why we should be worried about those.
The world identifies about one new pathogen every year. Covid is certainly the most disruptive pandemic in a century. Of course, HIV still has the dubious distinction of having killed more people than covid has so far, so [covid is] not even the deadliest pandemic of our lifetime. There could be a future pandemic that’s even more contagious, even deadlier, that’s harder to make a vaccine against.
One type of scenario that would be very concerning: What would happen if some of the vector-based diseases became deadlier? I think about, for example, tick-borne disease. In the U.S., there are three or four hundred thousand cases of Lyme disease every year. Now, around the world, there are ticks that carry Ebola-like illnesses … What would happen if the ticks in the U.S. were to get infected with an Ebola-like illness, so instead of worrying about Lyme disease you had to worry about something that could cause you to bleed to death?
H202: So what do we need to do to prevent another pandemic?
Fundamentally, microbes outnumber us, and we need to outsmart them. The only way we can do that is by working together and breaking the cycle of panic and neglect. We see this with every emergency. There’s panic. Money is spent on public health, and then it goes out of the headlines and the money dries up. That’s exactly what happened with Ebola.
The main thing we need to do is break the cycle of panic and neglect. And the way to do that, I believe, has to do with the budget. The Bipartisan Policy Center has recently released a report on this, which updates a proposal we made a little over a year ago with bipartisan support that would have allowed for Congress to have a way of funding preparedness that doesn’t rob Peter to pay Paul. Because currently what happens is if Congress wants to increase funding for preparedness, they have to cut funding for something like Alzheimer’s research or Early Head Start. That’s the terrible dilemma.
There’s a real analogy to after 9/11. After 9/11, a lot of money was spent on strengthening defense systems In the U.S. and globally, and Congress realized that money was going to dry up and there was a real risk the investments would be lost, so they created what was called the Overseas Contingency Operations fund.
H202: Are there other reforms to make the CDC and other agencies nimbler, besides increasing budget?
Absolutely. One is: We need to understand what went wrong with the lab tests. During my time at CDC, we had H1N1, and we had a lab test within two weeks. We had a million copies of it going out within days. For years after, countries went to thank me for the CDC test. So the stumble of CDC’s lab in February [with the release of flawed coronavirus tests] was costly, both in lives and credibility. We need a full and open understanding of what went wrong and an approach to make sure nothing like that can go wrong again.
Second is, I think CDC needs to up its game in terms of being well-aligned with state and local health departments, and the way to do that is for them to embed thousands of staff in state and local health departments, who then rotate back into CDC so there’s more common vision about what’s needed and what works in public health. I also think CDC needs to be more insulated from politics.
[But] it’s not about CDC only. CDC can only do what Congress funds it to do, and it can only succeed when state, city and local public health are competent. You had a lack of credibility, and then you had a sidelining of public health. I think you have to ask: Was this a failure of public health, or was it a failure to empower public health to succeed?
H202: We’ve talked about how to prevent a future pandemic. But this pandemic is not over.
Here’s a stunning fact: More people have died of covid-19 since the vaccine was developed than before the vaccine was developed.
H202: What should the Biden administration be doing now?
Right now, it needs to be forcing Moderna to do technological transfer so that we can ramp up manufacturing of mRNA vaccines to manufacturing hubs around the world.
The math on this is very clear. We are billions of doses short. Billions. So yes, we should share more [doses] now, but even if we share more, it’s not going to meet anything like the need. That’s even if we don’t recommend boosters in the U.S. We’ve been saying this for a long time. The U.S. taxpayers funded the Moderna technology. Moderna has $12 billion in the bank. They are trying to keep a monopoly on technology that the U.S. taxpayers paid for.
H202: How should the debate over the origin of the pandemic inform our thinking about pandemic prevention?
In the big picture, we don’t know now and we may never know whether the pandemic emerged naturally as SARS-1 in 2003 is believed to and likely did, or from a laboratory accident, as we know has happened in other situations. For example, the last case of smallpox in the world was because of a laboratory error in the United Kingdom. We know that the anthrax attacks in the U.S. likely came out of a laboratory. There’s pretty good evidence that an influenza pandemic in the late 1970s emerged from laboratory error either in the Soviet Union or elsewhere.
Because of that, I think my belief is we really need to do much better in two ways. We need to do better at assessing laboratory safety and improving it, and second, we need to do better at reducing the risk of spillover events.
Ahh, oof and ouch
AHH: Today the Biden administration will tell Americans to get a booster shot eight months after their first inoculation.
Health officials are expected to outline the plan during a White House covid-19 briefing, with President Biden slated to speak on the new recommendations directly afterwards, White House press secretary Jen Psaki said yesterday.
"Growing fears that the swift-moving delta variant of the coronavirus could ignite a firestorm of serious illness — resulting in a further spike in hospitalizations and deaths — prompted a forthcoming announcement by the Biden administration to recommend booster shots for the millions of Americans who have been vaccinated,” The Post's Tyler Pager, Laurie McGinley, Dan Diamond and Lena H. Sun report.
“Data from an array of sources — including the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Mayo Clinic, and Israel — shows immunity from the vaccines declines over time and suggests that greater protection may be needed to fight off the highly contagious variant, according to several senior officials who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss internal deliberations.”
The news about the administration’s plan is drawing both praise and criticism.
“Supporters welcomed the move, citing the worrisome turn in the pandemic,” our colleagues write. “Critics said the United States should not give out extra doses until more of the global population gets a first round of shots. Others complained the decision to recommend boosters, even tentatively, could interfere with the standard Food and Drug Administration process for weighing extra doses.”
OOF: Florida will punish two school districts that are requiring mask-wearing.
State education officials voted yesterday that two school districts violated state law by requiring students without medical exemptions to wear masks, The Post's Meryl Kornfield reports.
“The decision against districts in Broward and Alachua counties would be the first sanctions since DeSantis threatened to withhold money from districts that require face coverings, saying that parents should decide whether their children wear masks at school,” Meryl writes.
“The state’s Board of Education, whose members are appointed by the governor, decided that the local school officials should be investigated and possibly punished, following input from Florida Education Commissioner Richard Corcoran, who argued that the districts were not in compliance with the law,” Meryl adds. “Corcoran also pushed back against the Biden administration, which wrote to him and DeSantis last week saying federal funds could be available to school administrators who faced repercussions from the state.”
“My recommendation is every school superintendent have to comply with the law, whether they agree with it or not,” Corcoran said.
OUCH: Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) tested positive for the coronavirus.
“Abbott is among the Republican governors who have resisted public-health mandates aimed at stemming the tide of the virus’s delta variant,” The Post’s Felicia Sonmez reports. The governor has defended his executive order banning local governments from issuing mask mandates, even as a surge in coronavirus cases in Texas has overwhelmed hospitals.
Abbott said in a video posted on Twitter that he has been vaccinated against the coronavirus “and that may be one reason why I’m really not feeling any symptoms right now; I have no fever, no aches and pains, no other types of symptoms.”
Videos and photos posted online by Abbott’s gubernatorial campaign show him mingling indoors with a maskless crowd of more than 100 people indoors at an event in Texas on Monday night. While a spokesman for Abbott said everyone the governor had been in close contact with on Tuesday had been notified, the governor's office did not immediately respond to a query from The Post on whether those who attended Monday's event had been contacted.
CNN's Ram Ramgopal:
More in coronavirus news
Public health experts weighed in on what is safe for the vaccinated to do as coronavirus cases spike around the country.
Stat contacted three dozen epidemiologists and immunologists to see how they were navigating the risks around the pandemic. The medical news site asked the experts how willing they were to engage in different activities assuming they were vaccinated.
- None of the 27 experts who responded said they would send their unvaccinated child to school without a mask. It was the only question to earn a unanimous response.
- Responses were mixed, but experts were uncomfortable eating indoors or going to a movie theater. Eighteen of 27 respondents said they would not eat indoors at a restaurant. Most also said they would not see a movie indoors. But not all indoor activities were off-limits. All but four were willing to go to a hairdresser or barbershop, with most saying they would wear masks.
- Moving things outside made a difference. More than half of the experts said they would attend a large outdoor concert or sporting event.
- Stat also asked the 18 physicians in the group whether they would recommend patients who received a single shot of the Johnson & Johnson vaccine get a dose of another vaccine. Eleven said no; six said yes; and one researcher who advises the CDC pleaded “no comment.”
Elsewhere in health care
Health-care use has not fully rebounded.
Early data from 2021 shows that health-care utilization remains below what would be expected based on pre-pandemic levels, an analysis from the Kaiser Family Foundation finds. Using data from the Epic health records system and Bureau of Economic Analysis data on health-care spending, researchers found that hospital admissions were only 85.5 percent what would be expected based on historical patterns, while health-care spending was more than 7 percent below what would be expected.
“The persistence of lower-than-expected utilization suggests some of the care that did not occur early in the COVID-19 pandemic was foregone rather than simply delayed,” the researchers write.