The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

Auschwitz is a sacred place of Jewish memory. It’s no place for a Catholic church.

The entry to the concentration camp Auschwitz-Birkenau, Poland, in February/March 1945. (AP Photo/Stanislaw Mucha)
Placeholder while article actions load

This week marks the 70th anniversary of the 1945 liberation of Auschwitz, the notorious death camp in Poland at which 1.1 million Jews were murdered during the Holocaust. With each passing year, fewer survivors remain. The time is not far off when there will be no living witnesses to share their part in this story, to say: Yes, this happened, and this is how. We cannot allow evidence of the atrocities of the Holocaust to be co-opted by other groups for other purposes.

That is why Jews the world over were appalled when, in 1984, Carmelite nuns took over an Auschwitz building that had once stored the Zyklon B gas that Nazis used to murder Jews. With the full support of Polish Cardinal Franciszek Marcharski, local authorities granted the nuns a 99-year lease to convert the building into a convent, where the nuns sought to pray for the souls of the murdered. Around this time another affront took place, this time at Birkenau — also called Auschwitz II — when the local Catholic community established a working church in what was once the Nazi commandant headquarters.

As a rabbi, I have deep respect for all places of worship. I also feel that Christian houses of worship do not belong at what is in effect the largest Jewish cemetery in the world. And so in July 1989, I joined a group of seven activists protesting the Carmelite convent. We climbed over the fence surrounding the convent and peacefully assembled. Polish workers inside the convent poured a bucket of water mixed with urine on us, as nuns watched from the windows. In 1993, Pope John Paul II himself ordered the nuns to leave, and the convent was shut down.

Though that closure was a victory, the larger affront, the Parish Church of Brzezinka, remains. Former priest James Carroll eloquently describes this offense in his book “Constantine’s Sword: The Church and the Jews,” writing, “When suffering is seen to serve a universal plan of salvation, its particular character as tragic and evil is always diminished.”

“[T]he elimination of Jewishness from the place where Jews were eliminated,” Carroll continues, makes “the evil worse.”

And so in 1995, on the 50th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz, I again joined activists, this time for a sit-in at the Birkenau church. After a standoff with church officials that lasted throughout the day, we were arrested and taken to a police station, where a doctor summoned there asked that we strip. Flabbergasted, I blurted out, “You mean you haven’t stripped enough Jews in this place?” We were held for several hours before being released. Our protest and arrest won no concessions from the church or Catholic hierarchy.

The church remains, and its very existence at this sacred Jewish space is inappropriate, misleading and a violation of Shoah memory. A hundred years from now people will look to the camp for evidence of what occurred there. If the church structure remains, its large cross casting a shadow over Auschwitz II, the site could suggest to the uninformed that the Holocaust was either an attempt at Christian genocide or that the church defended Jews at that time – when in fact the church turned its back on the large-scale attempted annihilation of the Jewish people. If we as a humanity are to learn from our history, to strive for a better future, we need to know what has passed before us. Otherwise, we perpetuate the possibility that the atrocities of the past will repeat in the future, and that untold suffering will prevail.

It’s up to people of moral conscience to raise a voice for the sake of Holocaust memory and declare loud and clear: A church has no place at Auschwitz II. It’s also within the power of Pope Francis, who has shown himself to be a great friend to the Jewish community, to order the congregation to leave. The building should become a museum, specific to Birkenau, showing how the Nazis carried out their atrocities there. The large crosses in front of and on top of the building should be removed. The memory of the Jews murdered there — murdered because they were Jews — must be recognized with historical accuracy.