Warring cousins, a grisly execution: A Tunisian family torn apart by ISIS

Warring cousins, a grisly execution

A Tunisian family torn apart by ISIS

Published on April 23, 2017


One evening last fall, the Islamic State fighters came down from the mountains.

Note: Fadha Ghozlani shows a portrait of her brother Sayed, who was killed by Islamic State militants in their family house. Among Sayed’s attackers was a cousin.

Sayed Ghozlani was visiting his family during a break from the army, and the fighters wanted to find him. They stormed his house during dinner and corralled the men. They beat them up, tied their hands behind their backs and forced them all to kneel.

Then one fighter pressed a gun against Sayed’s head and demanded his name.

“Abdul Malik,” he replied.

“That’s not the truth,” another militant said in a voice that was familiar, according to two witnesses.

His face bloodied, Sayed looked up to see a figure carrying an AK-47 rifle and smiling triumphantly.

It was his cousin, Muntasir.

In the mountains of western Tunisia, radical Islamists are spreading their ideology, cowing villagers with brute violence and dividing families. American-trained Tunisian soldiers are battling them, but the militants are formidable opponents.

The struggle lays bare the Islamic State’s aspirations as it loses territory in Iraq and Syria, security officials and analysts say. The militants are searching for new safe havens and areas where they can impose control and sow chaos. They are also fortifying existing footholds to expand their reach and fallback options.

In Egypt, Islamic State militants are staging devastating attacks on minority Christians. In Algeria and the Sahel region, new Islamic State affiliates have emerged. And after losing its Libyan stronghold of Sirte in December, the Islamic State is trying to regroup in southern Libya, and potentially in Tunisia and other neighboring countries, U.S. military and intelligence officials say.

“The instability in Libya and North Africa may be the most significant near-term threat to U.S. and allies’ interests on the continent,” Gen. Thomas D. Waldhauser, head of the Pentagon’s Africa Command, told the Senate Armed Services Committee last month.

The return of possibly thousands of fighters threatens to further destabilize this moderate Muslim North African nation, the only one to emerge as a functioning democracy after the 2011 Arab Spring uprisings.

Less than 15 miles from the Algerian border, the mountains have become a crossroads for militants from the region. Caves and bushes provide plenty of cover for training camps and redoubts in an area that is partly ungoverned.

In villages and towns, the forces abetting radicalization are in full gear: Ignored by successive governments, the region is beset with high unemployment, poverty and weak social services. Resentment toward the government runs deep.

On that November evening, these colluding forces led one cousin to betray another.

“Ever since my brother joined the army, our cousin wanted to kill him,” said Fadha Ghozlani, 35, who was in the house during the attack, along with their younger brother, Mohammed. “He brought the terrorists to our home.”

Karma is one of the poorest neighborhoods in Kasserine. Dozens of families have sons who have joined the militants.

Spreading radicalism

By U.N. estimates, at least 5,500 Tunisians have fought for the Islamic State and al-Qaeda in Syria, Iraq and Libya — more than from any other country. Many are from the Kasserine region.

But even as Tunisia became a militant pipeline to the wars in those countries, its secular history and drift toward the West made it a target. In 2015, Tunisian gunmen thought to have trained in Libya attacked the resort town of Sousse and the Bardo Museum in the capital, Tunis, killing scores, mostly foreign tourists.

Last year, Islamic State fighters based in Libya brazenly battled security forces in the southern border town of Ben Guerdane, widely seen as an effort to establish a new foothold in Tunisia.

That foothold seems to be taking shape in these mountains, where the Islamic State is also in a contest with al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb, or AQIM, for recruits and territory.

Many AQIM fighters have defected to form the Islamic State’s Tunisian branch, Jund al-Khilafah, which in Arabic means the Soldiers of the Caliphate, security officials and analysts say.

There are no more than a couple hundred militants in the mountains, security officials say, including some from Algeria, Mauritania and West African countries. But most of the fighters are Tunisians from the area, disaffected men such as Muntasir.

By the time he joined the Islamic State last summer, it had become harder to travel to the wars abroad. The nation is under emergency law. Men under 35 need written permission from their parents to leave the country. A 125-mile earthen wall was built along the border with Libya to prevent jihadists from leaving and entering.

“The security situation is improving,” said Yasser Mesbah, an Interior Ministry spokesman. “But we can’t say the threat is over.”

Consider this: 3,576 Tunisians were tried last year on terrorism-related charges, including recruitment and training, according to Interior Ministry data.

“The bigger issue, not just for Tunisia, but for all of us, is this: What about the guys who have not left the state to fight?” said Patrice Bergamini, the European Union’s ambassador to Tunisia.

“They are like ticking bombs.”

High unemployment and resentment toward the government have made the Kasserine region a key source of recruits for the Islamic State and other radical groups.

Quiet conversion

Sayed and Muntasir grew up near each other in Thmad, a bucolic village in the mountains. Born the same year, they played together and often slept in the same room. They were both tall, lean and handsome.

Their families, like others in their once close-knit community, farmed and grazed sheep. They celebrated holidays and festivals together.

By the time the cousins turned 20, the Arab Spring uprisings were transforming Tunisia. In Kasserine, violent protests in January 2011 played a central role in the ousting of dictator Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali. Like other interior areas, it had been ignored by the country’s northern elite for decades.

Neither cousin took part in the revolution. Muntasir was growing crops and tending his family’s sheep on the mountains. And by then, Sayed had joined the army to help support his parents and siblings.

But Sayed’s job drove the two cousins apart. Muntasir soon viewed him as a member of Ben Ali’s oppressive regime.

“When Muntasir learned that Sayed had enlisted in the army, he used to call him ‘tyrant,’ ” recalled Mohammed Ghozlani, 25, Sayed’s younger brother. “He used to throw this word in our faces whenever he saw us in a local cafe or other places. But at that time, he didn’t try to harm us.”

Mohamed Zorgui, a rapper and community leader, says that Islamic State flags were being displayed openly in 2013.

After the revolt, a new openness flourished. But that also paved the way for religious extremists to attract youths frustrated with the lack of opportunities. In mosques and Islamic education camps, imams implored young people to give up their Western ways and urged them to defend Islam.

Mohamed Zorgui, a rapper and community youth leader, recalled that in 2013 “the black Islamic State flags were being displayed openly in the city center.”

The flags are gone, but the sense of despair lingers.

The promises of economic growth that emerged after the revolution remain unfulfilled, and cafes are filled during the day with idle young men of working age.

“The youth have no idea what the future will bring,” said Mahmoud Kahri, a lawmaker representing Kasserine. “And the government has found no efficient way to address their problems.”

That has garnered more sympathy for the militants. In January, protests broke out in the town over the lack of jobs. Some youths burned tires. Others branded government officials “nonbelievers” and chanted “ISIS is coming,” Zorgui recalled.

In Karma and Zuhour, two hardscrabble enclaves in the town of Kasserine, dozens of families have sons who left to fight abroad or were recruited by the militants in the mountains.

Scrawled on the wall of a school in Zuhour are the words: “ISIS is lasting and expanding.”

“The youth have no idea what the future will bring. And the government has found no efficient way to address their problems.”

—Mahmoud Kahri, a lawmaker representing Kasserine

By all accounts, Muntasir was not a devout Muslim. He rarely attended mosque or prayed five times a day. But last spring, his relatives noticed that he started praying and engaging in discussions about Islam.

“Muntasir used to drink alcohol, and then, one day, he suddenly started to speak about religion,” Mohammed Ghozlani recalled.

Yet, Muntasir kept his Islamic State sympathies a secret, and many family members didn’t realize he had joined the militant group until he had vanished into the mountains during the Muslim holy month of Ramadan last summer.

Mafoud Bin Daraie, a 40-year-old imam and community leader, said the militants have largely drawn recruits from rural young men who “have wrong impressions of Islam or are very poor.”

He has tried to stop several Kasserine youth from heading overseas to fight or into the mountains.

But now the imam is a target.

Sheikh Mafoud Bin Daraie became a target after denouncing radical Islamist ideologies. A militant attempted to kill him in this room.

‘Fuel to the battle’

A few months ago, a Tunisian militant with a handgun entered Bin Daraie’s mosque during Friday prayers. But security forces were tipped off, and before he could pull the trigger, they grabbed him.

“They tried to kill me because I spoke out against them,” Bin Daraie said.

A few blocks from his mosque, a house is pocked with softball-sized holes from heavy gunfire. In August, security forces fought a nine-hour battle with militants holed up there. Two of the gunmen, along with a passer-by, were killed.

One day last summer, the militants accused Najib Guasmi, 37, a shepherd, of being an informant for the security forces.

“They killed him with a bullet to his head,” said his brother, Hadi.

The militants have also planted land mines, killing several civilians in recent months.

At least a dozen Tunisian fighters returning from Syria and Iraq have joined the militants, said Ridha Raddaoui, co-author of a recent report on terrorism by the Tunisian Forum for Economic and Social Rights.

As more fighters return, “they will be fuel to the battle in the mountains against the Tunisian state,” he added.

At checkpoints in the towns, Tunisian security forces search vehicles for weapons and bombs. Soldiers patrol in Humvees and armored personnel carriers. Suspected militants have been arrested and sent to jail.

But a recent visit to the mountains, under armed escort, revealed the security challenges on this vast terrain dotted with cactus and pine trees along dry riverbeds.

“There are fighters everywhere,” said a national guard commander, pointing at the mountains, a Belgian-made rifle slung over his shoulder. He spoke on the condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to journalists. “But we don’t have the necessary means and equipment to fight them.”

The security forces, he said, were stretched thin and lacked equipment to track down the militants.

“God is the only one protecting us now,” he said.

Tunisian army patrols the streets of the town of Sbiba in the province of Kasserine. Kasserine is an impoverished province in western Tunisia. The high unemployment rate and the lack of opportunities for young people made it an important recruiting area for ISIS and Al Qaeda.

A tragic return

On that November evening, Muntasir was determined to confront his cousin. By then, he was routinely coming down from the mountains to pick up food and supplies. Nearly half the village was helping the militants. The other half lived in fear.

Sayed, too, was coming home — despite the omens. On one visit, a cousin told him that if he had a gun he would kill him on the spot.

“I told my brother, ‘Don’t come to the house. Muntasir is watching you,’ ” Fadha Ghozlani recalled.

But Sayed was close to his mother, and she needed money.

As Sayed glared at Muntasir in their house, his mother began to cry. She begged Muntasir not to harm her son.

But the militants hauled Sayed into a guest room. Muntasir joined them.

Moments later, two bullets pierced the back of Sayed’s head.

Fadha, Salina and Mohammed Ghozlani had a brother who was killed by Islamic State militants last fall. They say a cousin was among the attackers.