It was 2005, and Tebow, not yet a celebrity, had plotted out his future. His voice wavered. A few minutes into the conversation, Tebow shed a tear. He wouldn’t play his senior season of baseball. He had decided to enroll early at Florida to pursue a football career.
“One of the hardest decisions I ever made was choosing to go football over baseball,” Tebow said this month of that day at Nease High, just south of Jacksonville, Fla. “It’s an itch I‘ve always had and a passion I’ve always had, and it didn’t go away after years.”
It has been more than 13 years since the day Tebow’s baseball career ended. Well, the day it could have ended. Now, just weeks into Year 3 of a rise through the minor leagues, Tebow is one step from the majors. One step from his ultimate dream, which he set out for after his professional football career ended. While his foundation was growing and he was working as an ESPN college football analyst, he considered how the rest of his life would go. Maybe he’d give his “first love” another try. Maybe he’d try to play in the majors.
As his baseball odyssey continues, the question is how he’ll handle the pitching while playing for the Class AAA Syracuse Mets. The task at hand: Cut down on strikeouts, hit for power, track down flyballs. In Class AA, he struck out in more than 30 percent of his at-bats, but he hit a respectable .273. Through nine games this season, he’s 5 for 31 with 13 strikeouts.
In addition to being one of the oldest hitters in the International League, Tebow is also among its worst, statistically speaking. His on-base-plus-slugging percentage of .461 entering Monday ranked 109th of 117 qualified IL hitters and last among left fielders.
But still, at 31, he believes he’s improving, though he knows it won’t get any easier. As the competition has gotten stiffer, he could quit the game. Yet he isn’t worried about how hard opposing pitchers are throwing, nor does he seem to worry about the possibility that his baseball journey could end in the minors. Since 1970, only seven athletes have played in both the NFL and MLB. He would be the eighth.
“Hopefully one day he’ll be batting third this summer, and I can tell him he’s getting called up,” Syracuse Mets Manager Tony DeFrancesco said. “We’re pleased right now. Everybody’s going to pound him inside until he proves he can hit the ball in. He’s shown he can drive the ball the other way. It’s no secret.”
Tebow, a chiseled 6-foot-3 and 245 pounds, won the Heisman Trophy at Florida in 2007. After leading the Gators to two national titles, he was selected by the Denver Broncos in the first round of the 2010 draft and signed a five-year deal that guaranteed him $8.7 million. He was traded to the New York Jets in 2012 and spent brief stints with the New England Patriots and Philadelphia Eagles, but he was released before the 2015 season. He finished with a career record of 8-6 as a starting quarterback.
At Florida, Tebow spent hours every day in Urban Meyer’s office, having long talks with his coach about football and life. DeFrancesco said Tebow has popped in to talk about at-bats — in a notebook, he jots down observations on each pitcher he faces — and off-field priorities, including his foundation and speaking engagements. He’s become so popular with fans in minor league cities that Terry Collins, a special assistant to the general manager for the Mets, calls him “the Cal Ripken of the minor leagues” mostly because he signs so many autographs.
He’s introduced himself to many of his teammates. He asks them about their at-bats, what they saw, and what they learned in previous seasons. “Hey,” he has said, “What do you think about this?” On a bus ride in spring training, he sat next to Syracuse hitting coach Joel Chimelis and asked questions about a few power hitters, including the New York Yankees’ Aaron Judge. After one of the first few team practices, once everybody had left, there was Tebow, hacking away by himself in the cage. He’s still playing catch up.
At the plate, Tebow maintains a basic stance, with a slight rock. His bat is nearly vertical. He bends his knees slightly, then uncorks. Power has always defined the baseball player he is: In high school, his team ended practice every day with on-field hitting, and the team wouldn’t pack up until Tebow hit the ball over the fence. To best maximize his natural power, he’s adopted a minimalist approach to his pre-pitch movements.
Defensively, he said he improved his reads off the bat this spring. He is catching flyballs with one hand, not two. He feels his arm strength, about average, has improved.
Teammates, meanwhile, emphasize aspects of his character as perhaps his greatest contributions. He wears No. 15 because, when he was 15 years old, he met a boy in the Philippines born with backward feet. “I knew for the rest of my life what I wanted to do,” Tebow said, “and that’s fight for people who can’t fight for themselves.”
From the beginning, there was no timetable on when Tebow would reach the big leagues, no expectation for how fast he’d prove he was — or wasn’t — capable of playing professional baseball, former New York Mets general manager Sandy Alderson said. The decision to sign him was based on, more than anything, his character.
“The Mets as an organization saw this as a no-lose proposition,” Alderson said last week. “The risk factors with some guys — a bad personality, or if he’s a jerk — those were eliminated with him since he’s so positive. We also knew that in the minor leagues, his optimism would have a long-term impact on his teammates. Minor league life is not pretty. The most impressive thing is that he’s stuck with this for so long.”
At first he was an ex-football player, a little too bulky and too stiff. He’s since kept much of his strength but increased his mobility. He’s simplified his stance and load, minimized his stride and shortened his swing. Mets General Manager Brodie Van Wagenen, Tebow’s former agent, said he thinks Tebow can play at the highest level should he continue progressing at his current rate.
“Right now, AAA is where he can help us most,” Van Wagenen said. “He lets the ball get deep in the strike zone, and he can capitalize on mistakes. How he does this year is the determining factor.”