The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

The Nationals rely on the ‘eye test’ to scout players. That’s not an option this year.

Mike Rizzo will have to navigate this trade deadline without the help of his trusted in-person scouts. (Greg Fiume/Getty Images)
Placeholder while article actions load

Kasey McKeon had a list of names that did not include Drew Pomeranz. He settled in behind home plate at Oracle Park in San Francisco. It was July 22, 2019, nine days before last summer’s MLB trade deadline. The Washington Nationals needed relievers, the Giants were selling, and so McKeon, Washington’s director of player procurement, was there to scout Will Smith and Sam Dyson in person.

Then Pomeranz made his first relief appearance of the season, having left the Giants’ rotation with a 6.10 ERA in 17 starts. Pomeranz faced six batters in two innings, struck out four and had McKeon finding a quiet spot to call General Manager Mike Rizzo. The left-hander looked electric. And just like that, the Nationals had a new top target.

“ ‘Pomeranz just came out of the bullpen and was lights out,’ ” Rizzo recalled McKeon telling him. “ ‘We got to get this guy.’ ”

The Nationals didn’t acquire Pomeranz. The price was too high. But that they keyed on him after an in-person scouting trip is relevant now, the last week of August, with the deadline looming Monday.

Scouts are not allowed inside ballparks because of the novel coronavirus pandemic. So a team such as the Nationals, relentlessly reliant on the “eye test,” is instead sorting through video, analytics and contacts to assess players at a critical point of a 60-game season. The Nationals need a reliever or two, could use a depth starter and would benefit from a veteran bat if the front office still feels, as it did a short while ago, that a stumbling club is worth adding to.

What does baseball sound like during a pandemic? Loneliness, and hope.

Rizzo, one of the last general managers with a scouting background, has lamented the lack of access for scouts in 2020. He hardly ever chases a player unless one of his trusted guys has seen him recently. The Nationals then often will get a second or third in-person opinion before making offers. But this year, with everything jumbled, the Nationals will have to trust a new process. It goes against their core beliefs.

“Obviously it’s much more difficult to make an assessment and evaluation with those means of viewing a player,” Rizzo said of watching video instead of live games. “So we have to really trust our scouts. We have to trust the backgrounds that we’ve had on players, hope we have a history of a player that you’re acquiring, not only the last couple of weeks of this season but in the past.”

Looking for pitching in July 2019, the Nationals liked Pomeranz, Chicago White Sox reliever Alex Colomé and Cincinnati Reds starter Alex Wood, among others. They made deals for Colomé and Wood that fell through the night before the deadline. The White Sox upped their ask, and the Reds, having added starter Trevor Bauer, wanted to keep Wood for a playoff push. That sent the Nationals scrambling for answers, and they landed on Daniel Hudson, Roenis Elías and Hunter Strickland for a group of a low-ranked prospects.

Washington had eyes on each pitcher. Their research on Strickland, though, shows a scouting method unavailable in 2020. He had made just four major league appearances while dealing with a Grade 2 lat strain. Three were in March, in the first days of the season, and the last one came July 28, right up against the deadline. But the Nationals had someone at his rehab stint with Class AAA Tacoma. They felt that was enough to gauge his velocity, the bite on his slider and his recovery from the injury before taking a run at him.

Now, with no minor league season, about 30 extra players are training at each team’s alternate site. Scouts can’t go to those, either, unable to see intrasquad games or bullpen sessions. In early August, MLB set up a video and data sharing network among alternate sites, giving teams the ability to gather fresh information and tape on players. Teams could choose whether to opt in, and the Nationals did not, according to a person with knowledge of the situation who confirmed a report by the Athletic. They can trade only players who are in their 60-man pool but can add available players to it while a deal is being processed.

Svrluga: Bryce Harper’s talent remains mesmerizing, and his baseball story is still being written

“The whole situation is fraught,” said an American League scout who spoke on the condition of anonymity to avoid repercussions from his club. “Even if you get data or video from an alternate site, you’re now trusting your competitors to give you the right angles, the right numbers and on and on? Everything can be framed. We’re talking about teams who will do anything for the tiniest edge and rightfully so.”

Nationals Manager Dave Martinez is tangentially involved at the deadline. Rizzo will ask for opinions on players Martinez has coached. If Martinez has recently faced them and sunk into scouting reports, that’s even better. Martinez’s view of in-person assessment is two-pronged: You can gauge a player’s instincts and closely observe his demeanor and how he interacts with teammates.

Maybe that’s watching him after a strikeout. Maybe it’s following his behavior in the dugout. Martinez recently noted that the Nationals will “sit on” a player for a week to 10 days if interested, underscoring their commitment to in-person scouting. They use it to both confirm or complement what’s gleaned from video and their data analysts. But when Martinez watched tape, he finds himself zeroing in on one aspect and missing many others.

“All they’re seeing is them playing,” Martinez said of how TV narrows the scouting lens. “For me, I know what kind of hitter or what kind of pitcher a pitcher is. But what does he do outside of that?”

So that’s absent now — the ability to track a player once the camera moves on. That and a calculated exchange of information; multiple scouts say they love to chat with one another at the field. (You would, too, if you spent half of most years in a Courtyard by Marriott.) While stationed at home, providing feedback from offices, living rooms and kitchen tables, a critical part of the process is watered down.

Without admission to Oracle Park, the Nationals may have never fell for Pomeranz, who had a 2.39 ERA in 25 appearances for the Milwaukee Brewers after the deadline. Who knows what they’re missing this year.

Read more on the Washington Nationals:

Boswell: Stephen Strasburg is hurt again. But he has proved he’ll come back strong again, too.

Nationals fire employee who threw two cups of hot coffee at woman in Dominican Republic

Rookie Luis García is mimicking Juan Soto in every way he can