The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

Army got its bowl game at last, but this broken system needs to be blown up

Army Coach Jeff Monken and his team celebrate a win over Air Force and a 9-2 finish. (Danny Wild/USA Today Sports)

Saturday was filled with euphoria on post at the U.S. Military Academy. Army’s football team had rallied in the final minutes to beat Air Force, 10-7, on a frigid evening. A week earlier, the Black Knights had beaten archrival Navy, so Saturday’s win gave them the Commander-in-Chief’s Trophy for the third time in four years.

Saturday’s win also left them with a 9-2 record and one remaining question: Who would their opponent be in the Independence Bowl, scheduled for the day after Christmas?

By dusk Sunday, the answer had landed with a thud: no one. The Independence Bowl’s other participant was supposed to be the No. 5 team from the Pac-12. Because only Oregon and Colorado from that conference opted to take part in bowls, the Independence didn’t have an opponent for Army. After scrambling to try to find another team, the bowl gave up and canceled the game, leaving Army without a postseason destination.

On Monday evening, the story had a happy ending, brought on by another unhappy occurrence: Tennessee, which had accepted a bid to the Liberty Bowl in spite of its 3-7 record, had to drop out of the New Year’s Eve game because of coronavirus issues within its program. As a result, the Black Knights will now play West Virginia.

Army had been the first team in the country to accept a bowl bid in this virus-rattled season, formally being invited to play in Shreveport, La., in October after raising its record to 6-1. The trip to the Independence Bowl had been locked in by a deal between the school and the bowl that calls for Army to play there — if eligible — this season and then again in 2022 and 2024.

Which leads to this: The bowl system is so completely broken and corrupt that it needs to be blown up from top to bottom. Not tweaked. Not recalibrated. Blown up.

The bowl schedule is filled out, but it’s altered and diminished by the coronavirus pandemic

Everyone knows the CFP — the College Football Playoff, or is it the College Fraud Playoff? — is a cartel that makes it possible for only the 65 teams from the Power Five conferences to take part. Take it a step further, and only a few of those power teams have a realistic chance to qualify. In the seven years of the CFP, five schools have received 22 of the 28 bids: Alabama and Clemson (with six each); Oklahoma and Ohio State (four); and Notre Dame (two).

Cincinnati, out of the American Athletic Conference, went 9-0 in a season in which it couldn’t schedule a power conference school because most were playing either conference-only or conference-plus-one schedules. Notre Dame did schedule South Florida as its plus one. USF did win one game during its 1-8 season, beating The Citadel — a Football Championship Subdivision team — in its opener. The truth is, had the Bearcats scheduled and beaten the Kansas City Chiefs and Green Bay Packers, they wouldn’t have had a chance to make the four-team field.

Each year, the CFP trots out an athletic director or commissioner to represent its 13 members. This season, it was Iowa Athletic Director Gary Barta. When he was asked Sunday why Cincinnati was ranked eighth by the committee — behind two-loss Oklahoma and three-loss Florida — Barta warbled for a while about how much respect the committee had for Cincinnati before finally saying, “We didn’t think their résumé was as good as Oklahoma or Florida.”

Well, that certainly explains it.

Barta, it should be remembered, was once asked about expanding the CFP to eight teams to give more teams (read, more non-Power Five teams) a chance to take part. He said that would be too “complicated.” Perhaps he also thinks adding two plus two can be complicated.

As the highest-ranked Group of Five team, Cincinnati now gets to play in the Peach Bowl against Georgia — in Georgia. Meanwhile, Coastal Carolina, also undefeated, gets to play in the iconic Cure Bowl against unranked Liberty. Oregon, which didn’t win its division in the Pac-12, plays in the Fiesta Bowl, one of the four big-bucks but non-playoff New Year’s Six bowls, while three-loss North Carolina will play in the Orange Bowl. Why? Because of conference tie-ins that require Power Five teams to get first dibs.

Two Group of Five teams in the New Year’s Six bowls? That’s as likely as a CFP chairman actually answering a question.

Brewer: The College Football Playoff is set. Whether it was worth it depends on whom you ask.

And then there’s Army. Until Monday night’s reversal, the Black Knights were 9-2 with no place to go. In the meantime, nine teams with losing records, including six from the SEC, had been selected for the 28 bowls that managed to piece together matchups.

In a normal year, there would be 43 bowls. Almost all have contracts with conferences requiring they take a team from that league. Generally speaking, Power Five conferences have between six and eight guaranteed spots, excluding the CFP and the New Year’s Six bowls. That’s why South Carolina (2-8), Mississippi State (3-7), Arkansas (3-7), Tennessee (3-7), Kentucky (4-6) and Mississippi (4-5) received bowl invitations while Army waited nervously.

The Military Bowl, played in Annapolis, would have happily welcomed the Black Knights. Normally, that game matches a team from the AAC, Navy’s conference, with a team from the ACC. But because of opt-outs in those leagues, the game was unable to find an opponent for the Black Knights, who would no doubt have loved to play a bowl game on Navy’s home field. The game was canceled Monday.

Bottom line: Bowl tie-ins are a pox, and they shouldn’t exist. Once upon a time, before there were so many bowls, the guys in the ugly jackets jockeyed to get the best matchups possible. The only locked-in matchup was Pacific-8 vs. Big Ten in the Rose Bowl.

The system created some chaos, because back-room deals were often made before the date designated for bowl invitations. Locking in matchups seemed to make sense. Except the power conferences — surprise — have run amok locking in bids for their seventh- and eighth-place teams. Independents such as Army and Brigham Young must scramble for spots — which is why they are willing to accept tie-ins well in advance to ensure they have a place to play. BYU is already committed to the Independence Bowl in 2021, 2023 and 2025.

So, here’s what you do to create a better — if still imperfect — system.

  • Switch to an eight-team playoff, with two spots guaranteed to Group of Five teams. Blow up the current selection committee and create a committee with one rep from each of the 10 Football Bowl Subdivision conferences and two media members to keep an eye on things. Notre Dame no longer has its own vote; it is represented by the ACC.
  • All bowl tie-ins go away. Each bowl is free to make the best deal it can, but no one can be invited until the day after the conference title games. (Army and Navy can be given conditional bids based on the outcome of their game the next week.) If a bowl is caught jumping the gun and makes a backroom deal, it is stripped of its certification for the following year and the school or schools it made deals with can’t play in the bowl that season.
  • The NCAA agrees not to certify any new bowls unless one goes away. There are already far too many bowls; the world doesn’t need more of them.

In the meantime, thank goodness Army will get to play one more time this season. Its players have been on what amounts to lockdown since July. They have been on a completely empty post for more than a week now, after the rest of the cadets went home for the holidays.

All they wanted for Christmas was the chance to play one more game. Never has a football gift been more deserved.

What you need to read about college football

Scores | Rankings | Standings | Stats

Conference shakeup: The ground beneath college sports took its most disfiguring shake to date as Southern California and UCLA announced they are leaving the Pac-12 for the Big Ten.

Jerry Brewer: As college sports change, coaches must stop whining and amplify new voices.

Name, image and likeness: As NIL money keeps rising for players, coaches like Jimbo Fisher and Nick Saban are lobbing accusations at each other while most Americans are still enjoying college sports, a Post-UMD poll finds. The NCAA has issued guidelines for schools, but boosters like Miami’s John Ruiz aren’t worried.

USC’s fever dream: At the Trojans’ spring game, minds long addled with college football might struggle to remember where all of the players and coaches used to be.

Season wrap-up: College football can’t ruin the magic of college football, no matter how hard it tries.

Barry Svrluga: Kirby Smart finally vanquished Nick Saban, and now college football feels different.

John Feinstein: Don’t underestimate Deion Sanders — and don’t take your eyes off him.