In a statement after its passage, state Sen. Luis Sepúlveda (D) said that “this legislation will not only provide undocumented immigrants with a legal solution to obtain a driver’s license, but its positive impacts will include significant economic growth, improved road safety and keeping hard-working families together.”
But Michael Kearns, the Erie County clerk, says he refused to comply because he thinks it is in violation of federal law and could have negative consequences on state and election security.
On Tuesday, hours after Cuomo signed the bill, Kearns sent a letter to Erie County Attorney Michael Siragusa declaring, “I will not be granting driver’s licenses to illegal immigrants” and said that he planned to take action in federal court. He told The Washington Post on Wednesday that he hoped the courts could clarify whether county clerks could refuse to comply with the law and whether the legislation was legal in the first place.
Kearns said he thinks the law, whose justification includes “the long-held need by undocumented immigrants and workers to secure driving privileges not only to get back and forth to work but to conduct tasks in their personal lives,” is in violation of the Immigration and Reform and Control Act of 1986, which prohibits employers from knowingly hiring undocumented immigrants.
“This was a hastily passed bill, hastily signed by the governor,” he told The Post. “There’s going to be many unintended consequences, and we’ll be talking about them in the next couple months.”
Kearns said he was worried that his staff, which was already strained by Real ID applicants seeking enhanced licenses required for domestic air travel and certain federal purposes, would now have to deal with a new influx of customers. He also said they were not trained to verify foreign means of identification that were approved by the bill, which include a valid foreign passport, consular identification document or a driver’s license from the applicant’s country of citizenship.
New York residents can also register to vote when they obtain a license, and Kearns worried that a noncitizen could “purposefully or inadvertently” do so. “This would be an all-out opportunity for someone who has broken the law,” Kearns said.
He said his office frequently issues licenses to noncitizens who are in the United States legally, including immigrants, students and refugees, but they are required to provide documentation of their immigration status.
Kearns is not the only county clerk to resist the new law. Rensselaer County Clerk Frank Merola told News 10 ABC that he would refuse undocumented immigrants driver’s licenses because he worried that it would become difficult to distinguish them from citizens.
“There’s no right to a driver’s license. It’s a privilege. It’s not a privilege we should be giving to someone that’s here illegally,” Merola said. “I’m not anti-immigrant. My wife is a naturalized citizen. My son is also a police officer, so I think more of law enforcement. I’ve never heard anybody in law enforcement come out and say this is a good idea. Not at all. It puts them in a tough position. They’re at a disadvantage here. We’re going to give them a license that looks just like yours or mine. They wouldn’t even know that they’re here illegally.”
Emma Kreyche of Green Light N.Y., a coalition of activists who campaigned in support of the bill, dismissed claims that the new law could lead to noncitizens voting. “There’s no evidence to support this claim. I think it’s a smokescreen,” she told The Post. “Undocumented immigrants are not interested in committing crimes that would lead to their deportation. People just want to drive. This is a red herring.”
She said that undocumented immigrants would be able to obtain only standard licenses that cannot be used for federal purposes.
Kreyche said the law would “improve immeasurably the lives of hard-working New Yorkers” in multiple ways. Undocumented workers who labor near the state’s border with Canada often “live in fear” of being caught without a license, which could lead to deportation, she said. With driver’s licenses, Kreyche believes workers in the agriculture industry could feel more secure traveling to and from their jobs.
Getting a license would also enable undocumented immigrants to purchase cars and insurance, which Kreyche and other advocates say will generate economic activity and improve road safety.
She did, however, acknowledge that “there is a lot of work to be done to ensure its smooth implementation.”
“The bill itself leaves a lot to the discretion of the Department of Motor Vehicles commissioner” to set regulations about how to issue driver’s licenses to undocumented immigrants, Kreyche said. But she dismissed criticisms that the implementation would be too burdensome for state and local government.
The chief of staff to Sepúlveda, the bill’s sponsor, said processes were either already in place, or would be added, that would address concerns raised by critics of the bill.
“The reality is that [clerks’ offices] process foreign documents every day for multiple different types of applications, so there are already high security systems in place. This is just folding into things that already exists," Sophia Lajaunie said. She noted that about $33 million had been earmarked by lawmakers to support clerks’ offices and other local officials during the implementation period.
"There’s going to be a lot of education for the people at the DMV and the people who are applying” for the driver’s licenses, Lajaunie said.
New York becomes the 13th state, along with the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico, to allow undocumented immigrants to have some form of driver’s license, according to the National Immigration Law Center.