In the United States it costs, on average, $12,000 to have a baby.
— Bernie Sanders (@BernieSanders) March 6, 2019
In Finland it costs $60.
We've got to end the disgrace of our profit-driven health care system and pass Medicare for all.
Haley decided to weigh in. First, she said that Sanders should not be the one talking about how much more expensive it is for women in the United States, because he is not a woman.
Alright @BernieSanders, you’re not the woman having the baby so I wouldn’t be out there talking about skimping on a woman when it comes to childbirth. Trust me! Nice try though. https://t.co/LlmLmqdbNk
— Nikki Haley (@NikkiHaley) March 20, 2019
That’s an argument that will not be unpacked here, for Haley then went on to implicitly critique Finland’s health-care system.
Health care costs are too high that is true but comparing us to Finland is ridiculous. Ask them how their health care is. You won’t like their answer.
— Nikki Haley (@NikkiHaley) March 20, 2019
There are, of course, arguments to be made against pointing to Finland, a country with roughly the population of Minnesota, as a model for anything in the United States, a country with the population of Minnesota — 5.6 million — plus about 322 million more. One could say that Finland’s population is too small and homogeneous to serve as a model for the United States; one could say that Finland is not required to spend as much as the United States in other areas; one could skip all of this and head to a sauna. Any of those might have been controversial, but not quite so much as this.
For Haley implied that Finns are not happy with their health-care system and that, if asked, they would say as much. But the Finns did answer, and, oh, they did not say as much.
Nikki we have two children oldest born in U. S and younger one in Finland. You should ask my wife, you would not like the answer.
— Harri Karvinen (@HKarvinen) March 21, 2019
It's pretty great, thanks for asking.
— Taru Torikka (@tarutorikka) March 20, 2019
I am a Finn. I have been educated by Finnish public education system. I am a director with MSc in Economics degree. I have two children born in public hospitals. Our healthcare system is giving us excellent service. Finland was ranked yesterday the happiest country in the world.
— Arto Tamminen (@TamminenArto) March 21, 2019
Finland was indeed ranked the happiest country in the world on Wednesday; contributing factors to Finns’ happiness included their stated sense of social support and healthy life expectancy.
But happiness is not the only ranking the Finns are topping. A Global Burden of Disease study published last year found that Finland had one of the best health-care systems in the world. According to that study, Finland, Switzerland and Iceland have the best quality and most egalitarian systems, and, of the top nations, Finland’s health care had improved the most in recent years.
According to the same study, the United States had the world’s most expensive health-care system. U.S. News and World Report declared Finland to have the best public health-care system. In a 2014 study on infant mortality in the United States and Europe, Finland had the lowest rate and the United States had the highest.
Finland’s permanent representative to the United Nations, not content to let those studies speak for themselves, also pointed out to Haley that Finland’s maternal mortality is, according to the World Health Organization, the lowest in the world and that, per the OECD, Finland has the second lowest mortality from cancer of European Union countries.
What did Haley mean? Did she just walk into a diplomatic trap, some wondered?
Surprised the former UN ambassador fell victim to a classic blunder, the most famous of which is “never get involved in a land war in Asia,” but only slightly less well known is this: “never go up against a Nordic country when it comes to social service provision.” https://t.co/UMQezKZTwg
— Ken Schultz (@KSchultz3580) March 21, 2019
A spokeswoman for Haley did not immediately respond to a request for comment regarding what, exactly, Haley meant to imply about the health-care system of Finland, of all places.