Even as Merkel has demanded answers from Moscow, she has also showed little sign of wavering in her support for Nord Stream 2, a planned natural gas pipeline from Russia to Germany that the Trump administration has vehemently opposed.
It highlights the ongoing predicament for Berlin as it balances political differences with Moscow and deep economic ties. Now, as Western leaders face decisions on how to respond to the poisoning, those ties are under new scrutiny, both from within Germany and among other allies.
“His message is clear: Resistance to his regime is life-
threatening,” Norbert Röttgen, a senior member of Merkel’s Christian Democratic Party and head of the parliamentary foreign affairs committee, said about Putin as he called for Nord Stream 2 to be halted to punish him.
“In this context, diplomatic rituals are no longer enough,” he said.
White House press secretary Kayleigh McEnany said that Navalny’s poisoning was “reprehensible” and that Washington is working with allies “to hold those in Russia accountable wherever the evidence leads and restrict funds for their malign activities.”
But European diplomats were already cautioning about potential complications in imposing sanctions given that the poisoning took place on Russian soil, making it more difficult to investigate and determine who carried out the attack.
Nerve agents in the Novichok family were used in previous attacks blamed on Russian agents, and Yulia Navalnaya, Navalny’s wife, blamed “state terrorists” for the poisoning.
Novichok, developed in the Soviet Union, was used in the attempted assassination of former Russian spy Sergei Skripal and his daughter, Yulia, in Salisbury, Britain, in 2018. British authorities charged two Russian military intelligence agents in the poisoning, which British officials said was probably ordered at a senior level of the Russian state.
The fact that the attack took place in Britain made it easier to investigate and prove a connection to the Kremlin, said two European diplomats, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss confidential European Union considerations. It also killed E.U. citizens, meaning countries felt they had to impose swift retaliation, the diplomats said.
In Brussels, European Commission spokesman Peter Stano said new sanctions were not yet being discussed because the culprit has not yet been conclusively identified.
“This kind of chemical agent is not freely available. It was used on Russian territory against a Russian citizen,” Stano said. “We need answers. There needs to be an investigation.”
Putin’s spokesman, Dmitry Peskov, called on Europe and Germany not to rush to judgment, adding that Russia has little information on the basis of the German findings. He said any talk of sanctions against Russia was “unacceptable.”
“We do not understand the reason for raising the topic of sanctions,” he said Thursday. “We certainly would not want our partners in Germany and other European countries to rush to judgment. We would prefer dialogue.”
While Nord Stream 2 may be too close to completion for a change of course, Merkel’s sharp criticism of Moscow marked a shift, said Daniela Schwarzer, director of the German Council on Foreign Relations.
“There is a clear willingness to lead on the Russia issue,” she said.
Germany announced Wednesday it would consult with its allies on an appropriate response as Western officials expressed shock over the use of the nerve agent against the opposition leader.
“The main question is how far the [European Union] and particularly the U.S. will dare to go, given the damage that could be caused to them,” Ivan Timofeyev, program director at the Russian Council for International Affairs, told the business newspaper Kommersant.
Navalny, who fell ill Aug. 20 during a trip to Siberia, remains in a medically induced coma the Charité hospital in Berlin, where doctors have said his condition remains serious but is improving, though it remains unclear what the long-term impact will be.
“Alexei will certainly recover, and we will laugh at him again and whine that we do not want to be photographed for his Instagram a thousand times a day,” his wife wrote on an Instagram post showing a family selfie taken by her husband.
View this post on Instagram
Алексей обязательно поправится, и мы снова будем смеяться над ним и ныть всей семьей, что не хотим фотографироваться для его инстаграма тысячу раз в день. А государственные террористы так и останутся со своим новичком, заедая его рафаэлкой. И всегда будут жить с этим, сколько бы лет они не стояли со свечкой на Пасху в храме
Russian opposition figures have blamed the poisoning on Putin, given that Novichok is believed to be available only to state agencies.
But Russian officials Thursday doubled down on their denials that Navalny was poisoned inside Russia. State-controlled media outlets played down the incident and raised a whirl of doubt about the German findings.
The head of Russia’s Foreign Intelligence Service, Sergei Naryshkin, said the Navalny situation could be a provocation by Western intelligence agencies. “This cannot be ruled out,” he told Interfax news agency.
Dixon reported from Moscow. Fiona Weber-Steinhaus in Berlin; Michael Birnbaum in Riga, Latvia; and Felicia Sonmez in Washington contributed to this report.