FORT BENNING, GA. — The first female soldiers to complete the Army’s rigorous Ranger School pinned on their black-and-gold Ranger tab at a raucous graduation ceremony Friday, capping their history-making week and putting a spotlight on the debate over women in combat.
With family members, friends, an unusually large media contingent and an all-star cast of former Rangers looking on, 1st Lt. Shaye Haver of Copperas Cove, Tex., and Capt. Kristen Griest of Orange, Conn., graduated alongside 94 male soldiers at a ceremony on the shore of “Victory Pond.”
The women drew national attention for finishing the nine-week program, designed to test young soldiers’ leadership abilities, as the Pentagon approaches decisions on opening all combat positions to women who meet military standards.
Their success casts new attention on the obstacles that remain for women who aspire to join all-male combat units, including the 75th Ranger Regiment. Even while Haver and Griest are now Ranger-qualified, no women are eligible for the elite regiment, although officials say it is among the Special Operations units likely to be opened to women eventually.
Griest, 26, is a military police officer and has served one tour in Afghanistan. Haver, 25, is a pilot of Apache helicopters. Both are graduates of the U.S. Military Academy at West Point. Of 19 women who began the Ranger course, Haver and Griest are the only two to finish so far; one is repeating a prior phase of training in hopes of graduating soon.
Addressing the graduates, Maj. Gen. Scott Miller said no one should doubt that all 96 graduates met Ranger standards, regardless of their sex, and he congratulated them on proving their mettle.
“You’ll leave Victory Pond today with a small piece of cloth on your shoulder, but more importantly you carry the title of Ranger from here on out,” he said.
The Army allowed women into Ranger School for the first time this year as service leaders weighed opening more combat jobs to women. How far the military is willing to go toward ending restrictions on women will likely be evident soon.
Gen. Mark A. Milley, the Army’s new chief of staff, flew to Fort Benning to attend the graduation ceremony. He said he is proud of all the Rangers who completed the course and appreciates the importance of the pioneering performance of Haver and Griest.
“It’s a really big deal” for them and for the Army, he said.
Milley said he has not decided whether to recommend that all Army positions be opened to women. The only areas not already open to women are infantry, armor, certain artillery positions and the Special Operations forces, including the Ranger regiment.
“I believe the Army can adapt,” he said. “It has and will continue to adapt.”
Defense Secretary Ashton B. Carter said Thursday that he will decide by December whether to accept any recommended exceptions to an order — signed by one of his predecessors, Leon Panetta, nearly three years ago — that said all positions must be opened to qualified women unless service leaders can justify keeping any closed. Any recommended exceptions are due to Carter in October.
Griest told reporters Thursday that she hopes her success shows that women “can deal with the same stresses and training that men can.”
Some current and former military members feel strongly that the Pentagon is going too far to accommodate women.
James Lechner, a retired Army lieutenant colonel and former Ranger, said he questions whether the Ranger course adequately tested the female candidates under combat-simulated conditions and whether it makes sense to open all combat units to women.
“American women certainly serve with honor and distinction, provide some capabilities that males may not be able to provide,” Lechner said. “But when you talk about your fighting units, your combat arms units, especially the infantry . . . you don’t need to just have the minimum standards. You need to have as good as you possibly can get.”
Janine Davidson, a defense policy analyst at the Council on Foreign Relations and a former Air Force cargo-plane pilot, said the success of Griest and Haver and the prospect of the Army fully integrating women into its ground combat force is “policy catching up with reality,” given the extensive combat experience women had in Iraq and Afghanistan. It also reflects generational change that she says she has heard in conversations with high school students.
“They actually are shocked when they learn that women aren’t already doing this kind of stuff — the idea that they themselves would not be allowed to do it,” Davidson said.
Rangers call themselves “masters of special light infantry operations” such as seizing key terrain and infiltrating hostile territory by land, sea or air.