Government forces have recaptured around half of the area, and it now seems only a matter of time before Eastern Ghouta joins the list of locations clawed back from rebel control — by brute force, negotiated cease-fire or a mixture of the two.
As the largest rebel enclave on the outskirts of Damascus, Eastern Ghouta has long been a military priority for the government. Rebel artillery fired from Eastern Ghouta has for years posed the only real threat to the safety of citizens in the Damascus area. Now that loyalist forces have been freed up from other fronts, they appear intent on conquest.
“A cease-fire can’t happen if one side is winning and is well down the trajectory to victory,” said Faysal Itani of the Atlantic Council in Washington. “It’s going to be a tough, tough fight, but they have no reason to give a cease-fire.”
Doctors in Eastern Ghouta published photographs Tuesday of children they said had been burned by napalm. Chlorine bombs also have allegedly been dropped, despite warnings from senior U.S. officials that the use of chemical weapons might draw a military response.
The allegations can’t be proved because Eastern Ghouta is inaccessible. But “even if we cannot verify them, we cannot ignore them,” U.N. Secretary General António Guterres told the U.N. Security Council on Monday. “Syria is bleeding inside and out,” he said.
The violence comes despite a U.N. Security Council-mandated cease-fire that was to take effect over two weeks ago but instead seemed only to accelerate the killing. The Eastern Ghouta health authorities estimated Tuesday that more than 1,400 people have been killed since the Feb. 18 assault on the enclave began, with 840 of those deaths occurring since the Security Council adopted a 30-day cease-fire Feb. 24.
Addressing the Security Council on Monday, U.S. Ambassador Nikki Haley said the United States is prepared to act unilaterally to enforce the cease-fire if Russia does not comply.
Given its large population and distance from international borders and rebel-held territory to which the fighters and residents might easily escape, the only identifiable outcome seems to be outright military victory by the government.
The Assad government’s pursuit of a military solution over a negotiated settlement to the fighting “precludes any other option,” Sajjad Malik, the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees representative in Damascus, said in an interview last week. “And it’s really dramatic for the people. We’re seeing this played out in Ghouta as never before.”
A week ago, Malik accompanied the only convoy of aid to be allowed into Eastern Ghouta since November and said he was shocked by what he saw. Most people have spent the past three weeks hiding in basements and crudely built underground shelters, where conditions are rapidly deteriorating.
“There’s not enough food. There’s not enough medicines. There’s skin rashes because they haven’t washed in days. These people want either to stop the bombing or get out,” said Malik, who spent seven hours in Eastern Ghouta. What he saw, he said, “will stay with me forever.”
“The children are filled with trauma — you can see it in their eyes. They’re tired. They’re hungry,” he said.
As loyalist forces retake territory, civilians are being squeezed into an ever-smaller space. About 10,000 to 15,000 people are on the run, and local authorities say displaced people are camped out on the streets and in parks in the town of Douma, the area’s largest metropolis, because they have no other place to go.
In the basements and shelters, the question of whether to leave or to stay is a subject of debate. Some residents want safe passage out. Others would prefer a deal such as the one that ended the siege of Aleppo in 2016, with fighters evacuated along with any residents who wanted to depart, leaving the area under regime control.
“Our leaving the city needs assurances from the U.N. that the regime will not put us in detention and torture us. Russia is not enough to give these guarantees because they are a partner of the regime in killing our people,” Naamat, who would like to leave, said from the basement she has shared with 320 people from her area for the past three weeks. She spoke on the condition that her full name not be used for reasons of safety.
But such guarantees aren’t likely to materialize because there are no negotiations for any kind of deal. Guterres told the Security Council that Russia and the Syrian government had failed to respond to a U.N. effort to mediate with the largest rebel group, Jaish al-Islam, and that a separate effort with a smaller group, Faylaq al-Rahman, had foundered because of a dispute over where negotiations should take place.
On Tuesday, 31 chronically ill patients were evacuated from Eastern Ghouta under the terms of an agreement negotiated last year with the rebels that was never fully implemented. They were people with diseases such as cancer, diabetes and kidney failure who cannot be treated in the primitive medical facilities of Ghouta, and they were joined by around 140 relatives who took the chance to escape. Those critically injured by the bombardments were not part of the deal, even though at least 1,000 are in need of lifesaving care, according to the United Nations.
Humanitarian corridors opened by the government have drawn few people. Some residents told Malik that the rebels were preventing them from leaving.
Residents say the bombardments don’t stop for long enough for people to dare leave their basements to reach the crossing points. But even if they dared, residents fear what would happen when they encountered government forces across the front line.
In at least three towns in the area, local residents have staged pro-government demonstrations in recent days, waving the Syrian flag and denouncing the anti-Assad rebellion. “We don’t want freedom anymore. We want national unity,” a small crowd chanted Friday in the town of Kfar Batna.
The demonstrations were held in a bid to deter the Syrian government from bombarding the area, said Naamat. “They did that because they want only for the bombing to stop. They are trying to stop the regime and save their lives,” she said.
Zakaria Zakaria in Istanbul and Heba Habib in Stockholm contributed to this report.