The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

Cruise ship passengers riled over order for added 2-week coronavirus quarantine in U.S.

At the Munich Security Conference Feb. 15, WHO Director General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said the coronavirus epidemic remains an unpredictable threat. (Video: Reuters)
Placeholder while article actions load

YOKOHAMA, Japan — American passengers under coronavirus lockdown on the Diamond Princess cruise ship in Yokohama were told Saturday of U.S. plans to take them home. But some were outraged by the new rules: 14 additional days of quarantine back in the United States.

"It's completely devastating," said Karey Maniscalco, 44, of St. George, Utah. "If they wanted to keep us under quarantine for an additional period, they should have picked us up 10 days ago. They should have done their job."

The announcement was a shift from previous U.S. statements that the passengers were best serving out their quarantine aboard the ship, and that they would not have to undergo further quarantine once they returned home.

The Japanese government also announced that an additional 67 people on the ship were found to have the virus out of the latest batch of 217 who were tested, although more than half showed no symptoms. That brings to 285 the number of passengers and crew members who have been found to be infected out of 930 tested, more than 30 percent.

Live updates on the coronavirus outbreak

Maniscalco, who is self-employed, said the forced absence would harm her business. She said she thinks people testing positive for the virus probably contracted it before the quarantine period began but says the U.S. government should have sent experts at the start to assess whether the quarantine on the ship was effective.

“They should have done this on the very first day,” she said, close to tears. “And now, 400 American citizens are going to suffer because of their incompetence.”

Maniscalco doesn’t even know whether her husband, a Canadian citizen who owns a small business in the United States, will be able to travel with her.

“That’s basically a month of our lives we are being held captive,” she added. “And without just cause — we didn’t commit a crime.”

New cases on the ship

The ship, with 2,666 passengers and 1,045 crew members, began a 14-day quarantine on Feb. 5. The end was supposed to come on Wednesday, and passengers anticipated being able to return home. But as more tests were carried out, it became clear a high percentage of people had the virus, and experts warned there was a risk it could still be spreading on the ship.

In acknowledgment of those risks, Japan changed course and began evacuating some passengers before the quarantine period ended, beginning with people older than 80 and with underlying health problems. It also stepped up its program of testing passengers.

After initially backing Japan’s approach toward the ship, the U.S. government has now also implicitly acknowledged that the Diamond Princess may not have been the best place to keep the American travelers.

“We are deeply grateful to the cruise line and government of Japan for working diligently to contain and control the spread of the illness,” the U.S. Embassy in Tokyo wrote in an email to Americans on the ship.

“However, to fulfill our government’s responsibilities to U.S. citizens under our rules and practices, as well as to reduce the burden on the Japanese health care system, the U.S. government recommends, out of an abundance of caution, that U.S. citizens disembark and return to the United States for further monitoring.”

It was a decision some passengers said should have been made much earlier.

“Why didn’t they test everybody [earlier] and it would have been over?” asked Melanie Haering, 58, of Tooele, Utah, echoing a question many people have asked from the beginning.


Medical experts have expressed concerns that the virus could still be spreading on the ship, possibly through the crew, or even perhaps through the air conditioning system — although the captain has repeatedly assured passengers that the air in their cabins is fresh rather than recycled. More than 20 crew members have tested positive for the virus.

The embassy email said the State Department, working with the Department of Health and Human Services and other agencies, will provide a chartered aircraft to passengers directly from Japan to Travis Air Force Base in California, and for some passengers on to Lackland Air Force Base in Texas.

The plane will arrive in Japan on Sunday evening. Passengers will be screened for symptoms and then taken by bus to the plane. “We are working with our Japanese partners to ensure that any symptomatic passengers receive the required care in Japan if they cannot board the flight,” the embassy said.

“Travelers returning to the United States from high-risk areas are required to undergo quarantine. Accordingly, you will need to undergo further quarantine of 14 days when you arrive in the United States,” the email said.

“We understand this is frustrating and an adjustment, but these measures are consistent with the careful policies we have instituted to limit the potential spread of the disease.”

Passengers who choose not to return on this flight will be unable to return to the United States “for a period of time,” the embassy wrote.

Several passengers said they viewed the additional quarantine period as the wisest course of action but still found the news tough to process.

“Having hoped that three, four days from now, I’d be getting on a plane and this would be all behind me, now facing another 14-day quarantine in a military institution where the conditions — I imagine they’re obviously going to be more sanitary, but they’re going to be vastly different — it is frightening,” said Spencer Fehrenbacher, 29, a U.S. citizen whose family immigrated to Canada in 2016.

Japan relaxes cruise ship quarantine for elderly amid fears of virus spread

‘Dream job’ turns into ‘nightmare’: Virus fears grow among Diamond Princess crew

Cruise ship coronavirus infections double, exceeding the total for any country but China

Today’s coverage from Post correspondents around the world

Like Washington Post World on Facebook and stay updated on foreign news